Skip to main content

Progressive Rock Review: Not Otherwise Specified-Projective Instruments

Release Date: 25thFeb 2014
Label: Weeping Angel 
Although this is the second release from Not Otherwise Specified, going by the title of Projective Instruments, I must admit that this “band” had escaped detection under my musical radar. The “band” in question is a bit of a misnomer, in that Not Otherwise Specified is a one man, multi-instrumentalist Craig Kerley, and his debut release, which was well received, was the album, Judgment.

Apart from playing all the instruments on the album, Craig sings, and produced the album as well, although he does allow Jerry Guidroz (Neal Morse) to mix and master Projective Instruments.

Music wise, Craig does not meander much from the debut, which I’ve now listened to, but that does not mean this is in any way a retreading of paths already followed. Think Pink Floyd, early King Crimson evolving into Arena/Pallas and then venturing into the domain of Dream Theater and in that mélange somewhere you would find Not Otherwise Specified.

Projective Instruments is a 7 track album with a total playing time of around 63 minutes, with track 4, “Sorbet” at 2:38 minutes, the shortest on offer and then the epic “Racing Shadows” at 23:32 minutes, the longest piece on the album and is a 5 piece suite.

The album starter, “Harvest Soul” (9:46) is a storming piece of work. A genuinely heavy piece of metal, but thankfully  lacking the “growled” vocals, which blasts off immediately and then continues to fire on all cylinders, with some very melodic, almost gentle, passages. This is a terrific entry to the album Projective Instruments, which wants you to keep listening to what follows with interest.

“Hold On” (4:04) is again a track which demands attention with superb guitar, amazing synths and a powerful voice and also varies from areas of light and dark. The third track, “Falling” (11:20) fires up with some amazing bass, and is then joined with more guitar and keys. The main component of the tracks thus far, is to move easily from an all-out aural assault, to being gently subdued and this mixture of contrasts is excellent.

The short “Sorbet” (2:38) follows and is a gentle, haunting, acoustic track with superb acoustic guitar and ethereal/plaintive orchestral strings in the background built around a terrific melody line. From the shortest to the longest, “Racing Shadows” (23:32) , which can be split into 5 sections, “The Starting Line,”“Pitfalls,” I’m The Man”, “Fine Dead Song”  and  “Again.” A piano lead intro with excellent powerful vocals is soon joined by drums, bass and a wind instrument (possibly synth generated?) setting up a track that slowly builds. This is a real tour-de-force of a track with constant ebbing and flowing through many themes and ideas. From the simple, uncluttered areas, it can suddenly soar into a high energy workout. The playing time of this track is suitably disguised by the swings in the music that occur and the 23+ minutes appear to pass much quicker.

A very different track follows this epic with “Caveat” (3:56), which is an a cappella track starting with a solo voice and builds by adding others at different times and then stripping them away again. This is an unusual track that seems to work, but do not ask me why? 

The final track, “Signal To Noise” (8:10) has a mixture of radio voices/clips vying to be heard before a plaintive piano theme starts up and an emotive vocal builds, to be replaced shortly by strings and a plucked acoustic guitar, before the vocal reappears. Around the 3 minute mark, there is a fair amount of jagged guitar riffs over some feedback with the vocals drifting down into the mix. Chiming guitars build from around the 5 minute point, leaving the voice “screaming” somewhere, away in the background. The track then shifts completely with another passage of keyboards/strings, before the jagged guitar riffs re-enter the scene and the track is on its way out, having bludgeoned itself, in a strangely painless manner, into your brain.

Projective Instruments is a rollercoaster of an album, in that it can produce moments of sheer poetic music gentleness and just as suddenly sweep everything aside as it “wakens the beast” of pure metal. Not an album for the fainthearted, or those with delicate hearing, but an immensely satisfying listen for all of its 63 minutes. I think that you should clear a space on the shelf for this one.

4.5/5 Stars
Harvest Soul
Hold On
Racing Shadows
Signal To Noise

Key Tracks:  Harvest Soul: Racing Shadows: Caveat

Jim “The Ancient One” Lawson-Sr. Reviewer Prog Rock Music Talk

May 6, 2014

Review Provided By Prog Rock Music Talk


Popular posts from this blog

British Post-Punk Veterans 1919 Return With A Brand New Masterpiece Of Darkly Melodic Goth Rock, FUTURECIDE!

Los Angeles, CA - Like the mythic phoenix rising from the ashes, British post-punk band 1919 have gone through Hell and back over the course of their harrowing career, but they keep returning stronger than ever! Founded in 1980, the band released its debut album Machine in 1983 and one EP a year later before calling it quits. However, the band reformed in 2014 to great acclaim, performing numerous tours and at festivals across Europe. Then, tragedy struck as the band’s founding guitarist Mark Tighe was diagnosed with cancer in 2016 and succumbed to the disease in January 2017. Tighe insisted that the band should carry on without him, which they have done in finest form with their newest effort Futurecide. The album, which will be officially released on April 12 via Cleopatra Records, features brand new compositions and includes special guest performances by Tighe as well as former member Steve Madden, who also passed away this year. The first single, “Anxiety,” was released at the en…

Concert Review: Ghost At The Palace Theater Albany NY

Ghost At The Palace Theater Albany NY December 13, 2018

With winter upon us in the great Northeast, it was just another night. We never have a reason to stay in because of the weather, we just go. It so happened that it was a nice evening for a drive to a Ghost concert.We secured our tickets months ago and have been anticipating this night for months on end.
Last July I attended a “bucket list” concert, the great Iron Maiden was coming to Mansfield, MA. Opening for them was Ghost. This was a turn of a friendly card for the band, a great way to get worldwide exposure otherwise not afforded by a lesser band. They were already on the rise and the lead singer Papa Emeritus had a helluva a band (no pun intended there). At that time my prediction was that when the new year began Ghost would be headlining their own shows. So, then it happened, here we are tonight watching this incredible metal band headlining their own show, with no opener may I add.
For those of you unf…

Experience Hendrix Tour 2019 Concert Review

The Experience Hendrix Tour 2019 Concert The Palace Theater Albany, New York April 3, 2019

The pictures I have provided were snapped by me with my phone to give you an idea of the backdrop to the music prior to the show. That screen changed with each song and it was very trippy psychedelic colors and images that mirrored the timeframe of Jimi in his prime. -Keith “MuzikMan” Hannaleck
The Electric Church arrived in Albany, NY last night with its all-star cast for the Experience Hendrix 2019 Tour.The music of Jimi Hendrix continues to thrive and be embraced by fans worldwide. This is a tour I have been wanting to catch for several years now and I finally made it, and so glad I did.
The best thing that could happen to this event is the involvement of Billy Cox. Anyone familiar with Jimi’s music knows that they were friends for a long time and Billy played bass on some of Jimi’s albums. Also, with Janie Hendrix involved it makes everything legit. Also havin…